Home · Recipes Guinness Brownies with Butterscotch Fudge Author: Maryanne CabreraPublished: Jan 25, 2012Updated: Nov 13, 2023 View Recipe34 ReviewsThis post may contain affiliate links. Read our disclosure policy. Guinness brownies topped with butterscotch fudge and garnished with a crunchy salted pretzel. Think beer is just for drinking? Think again! Stout beer is a versatile ingredient. Use it to make stout bread! (Perfect for cheese sandwiches!) Satisfy your sweet tooth with stout ice cream. Or, make the ultimate game day brownies- Guinness brownies with butterscotch fudge and pretzel topping! Guinness Brownies I first created this recipe for a Super Bowl party. Beer and pretzels are bound to appear at every Super Bowl viewing party. Might as well add some chocolate to the mix! It’s a win-win situation. These brownies are perfectly portioned for a quick bite-sized treat. Each brownie bite is topped with one mini pretzel! See the three distinct layers? It’s everything you could want in a dessert. Sweet, salty, crunchy, and just slightly bitter. These Guinness brownies are dense and fudge-like in texture. The rich, luscious butterscotch fudge topping adds sweetness to the dark chocolate brownies. And, the salty pretzel adds that much needed crunch! Brownie Ingredients and Substitutions These Guinness brownies use a combination of chopped dark chocolate and unsweetened cocoa powder. Any kind of high quality dark chocolate (meaning at least 55% cocoa) works. I recommend Ghirardelli intense dark chocolate bars, Lindt excellent bar, and Trader Joe’s dark chocolate bars. Use regular, plain unsweetened cocoa powder. It is often labeled as natural cocoa powder. Stay away from CACAO powder. That’s an entirely different product. Recipe calls for dark brown sugar. Dark brown sugar has a tad bit more molasses than light brown sugar. Either sugar can be used. Dark brown sugar does provide a slightly richer flavor. The recipe calls for three extra-large eggs. However, you use an equal amount of standard large eggs to achieve similar results. The difference in amount between extra large and large is negligible for this recipe. I prefer to use mini chocolate chips for this recipe. The mini version adds the perfect little bite of extra chocolate. Feel free to sub in standard chocolate chips or chocolate chunks, if desired. However, it may be more difficult to achieve clean slices with the larger chocolate pieces. Is Stout Beer Necessary? Yes, the stout beer is a necessary. The Guinness flavor is not overpowering. Much of the beer’s alcohol is cooked off during baking. The chocolate batter and sweet butterscotch topping mellows out any bitterness from the stout beer. No need to use Guinness. Use any stout beer you happen to have. Depending on the season, there is a stout for every occasion! There are cocoa-infused imperial stouts during Valentine’s Day, gingerbread stouts during the holiday season, and even bourbel barrel aged stouts around Father’s Day. Take your pick and experiment! Mixing Brownie Batter This recipe works in a 9×13-inch baking pan or two 8-inch square pans.Start by melting the butter and chopped chocolate stovetop. Alternatively, you may gently melt the ingredients in the microwave in intervals at half power.Add granulated sugar and brown sugar to melted mixture. Some of the sugar will dissolve.Transfer mixture to a stand mixer with a paddle attachment or use an electric hand mixer and a large mixing bowl.Slowly incorporate eggs to batter, one at a time.Whisk dry ingredients in a separate bowl. Alternate adding dry ingredients and Guinness to batter. Start and end with the dry mixture.Fold in the chocolate chips. Then, transfer to prepared baking pan. Butterscotch Fudge What’s the difference between butterscotch and caramel? Butterscotch is simply made by melting together brown sugar and butter. Caramel uses white sugar cooked to an amber color. Turn butterscotch sauce into fudge by mixing it with powdered sugar (confectioners’ sugar or icing sugar) with cream. The creamy fudge will harden and set over time. The secret to these brownies are the salted pretzels that keep you coming back for more. This recipe makes about 40 bite-sized pieces. Storage and Leftovers These Guinness brownies with butterscotch fudge are best served the same day they are assembled. The exposed pretzels will stale overtime. If you plan of making these ahead of time (or want brownies that are better for leftovers), use chocolate cover pretzels for the topping. Guinness Brownies with Butterscotch Fudge 5 from 1 vote These Guinness brownies are topped with butterscotch fudge and garnished with a crunchy salted pretzel.Yield: 9×13-inch pan or two 8-inch square pans Prep Time: 25 minutes minutesCook Time: 25 minutes minutesCooling Time: 30 minutes minutesTotal Time: 1 hour hour 20 minutes minutes Servings: 35 pieces Print Recipe Pin Recipe Rate Recipe IngredientsGuiness Brownies3 oz unsalted butter8 oz dark chocolate, chopped½ cup granulated sugar½ cup dark brown sugar, packed3 extra large eggs1 cup all-purpose flour½ cup unsweetened cocoa powder¼ teaspoon fine sea salt1 ¼ cup (10 oz) Guinness, or any stout beer1 cup mini chocolate chipsButterscotch Fudge½ cup unsalted butter1 cup dark brown sugar, packed⅛ teaspoon kosher salt2 cups confectioners' sugar, sifted3 Tablespoons heavy cream½ teaspoon vanilla paste or pure vanilla extractsalted pretzels, as needed to garnish Instructions Guiness BrowniesPreheat oven to 350°F. Line 9×13-inch pan baking with parchment paper. Grease and set aside. In a large saucepan, melt butter and chocolate over medium-low heat. Once melted, add sugar and brown sugar. Stir to combine. Remove from heat.Transfer batter to the bowl of a stand mixer with a paddle attachment. Add eggs one at a time, making sure each egg is fully incorporated before adding the next.Whisk together flour, cocoa powder, and salt. Alternate adding dry mixture and Guinness to the batter. Starting and ending with the dry mixture. Fold in chocolate chips.Pour into prepared pan. Bake for 25-30 minutes until toothpick inserted in the center of the brownie comes out clean. Let cool on rack.Butterscotch FudgeIn a medium sauce pan, melted butter and brown sugar. Heat over medium heat until sugar mixture starts to boil. Let simmer for one minute. Then remove from heat. Add salt.In the bowl of a stand mixer with a paddle attachment, mix confectioners sugar, cream and vanilla. Once mixture is paste like, slowly add the slightly cooled butter-sugar mix. Beat at low-medium speed until thoroughly combined.Immediately pour over cooled brownies and level with an offset spatula. If desired, place pretzels on top of fudge. Let fudge set before cutting. Serve same day. NotesIngredients: Any kind of high quality dark chocolate (meaning at least 55% cocoa) works. I recommend Ghirardelli intense dark chocolate bars, Lindt excellent bar, and Trader Joe’s dark chocolate bars. Use regular, plain unsweetened cocoa powder. It is often labeled as natural cocoa powder. Dark brown sugar has a bit more molasses than light brown sugar. Either sugar can be used. Recipe calls for extra-large eggs. However, you may use an equal amount of large eggs to achieve similar results. Mini chocolate chips slices easier than if you use standard chocolate chips or chocolate chunks. Serving & Leftovers: Serve same day. Pretzels will get stale overtime. If the brownies are going to sit out awhile, I suggest chocolate covered pretzels. Author: Maryanne Cabrera Course: DessertCuisine: AmericanKeyword: guinness brownies, stout brownies, butterscotch fudge Did you make this recipe?Show us on Instagram! Tag @littleepicurean and hashtag #littleepicurean.
Tina says: January 25, 2012 These brownies look amazing! Love the pretzels on top and the fact that Guinness is in there. Very creative. I always find delicious things on your site, so not sure why I am not already a follower but I am now. Have a great day! Reply
Laura says: January 25, 2012 I just may have to try these…. Have an event coming up and these could be a hit!! :) Reply
Colleen Bierstine says: January 25, 2012 Whoa…what an amazing combo! Brownies and butterscotch as separate entities are fantastic enough. Together, they must be heaven. I love the little pretzel topper! Reply
the little epicurean says: January 26, 2012 I spread a thin layer of butterscotch on the brownies and saved the rest for myself! ;) Next time I make these I’ll have to use chocolate dipped pretzels because the pretzels get stale pretty quick.
lisaiscooking says: January 25, 2012 I love this idea–and I love pretzels with sweets and chocolate! Can’t wait to try these bars. Reply
the little epicurean says: January 26, 2012 The salt and crunch of pretzels surprisingly makes everything better! Hope you enjoy them :)
Rosie @ Sweetapolita says: January 27, 2012 Whoa! These look awesome. I will be making them later tonight and just shared on Facebook–too amazing not to! xo Reply
the little epicurean says: January 27, 2012 Thank you, Rosie! I really appreciate you sharing the post! :)
MyFudo™ says: January 27, 2012 Love the pretzels on top! Makes the sweet treats more delightful to my tastebuds, since there is that mild salty flavor to break the flavor. What a perfect way to enjoy game night. Lovely post! Reply
the little epicurean says: January 27, 2012 Thank you! Yeah, its pretty amazing how adding a little bit of salt can make the dessert taste so much better.
Union Street Eats says: January 27, 2012 I just made the Homer Simpson drool noise in my head when I saw this photo. PERFECT for those of us hosting a bunch of loud boys for the superbowl next week! Reply
the little epicurean says: January 28, 2012 Nom nom nom! I love The Simpsons. I’ve always wanted to make that donut with the sprinkles and pink glaze. Have fun with the boys next Sunday!
Twin Tables says: January 27, 2012 Um…wow. Guinness is good, butterscotch is amazing, pretzels are my favorite snack but combining them all together??? Pure Genius! Reply
the little epicurean says: January 28, 2012 I used a really sharp 9 inch chef’s knife. Get the sharp point on one end of the brownies then cut down. Don’t drag the knife, just let it chop through the brownies then bring it back up. Wipe it clean and cut again.
Amanda says: January 31, 2012 These look delish! I’m sure they were more fun to make than understanding the rules of football! Our food lovers would LOVE this. We’d love if you’d check it out and contribute! http://bit.ly/yI0sZU Cheers! Reply
Anonymous says: February 4, 2012 What kind of dark chocolate? Semi-sweet? Bittersweet? Unsweetened? Reply
the little epicurean says: February 4, 2012 Any dark chocolate with a cacao percentage between 50 and 75 works well. I use a mixture of Theo Chocolate 70% cacao and Ghirardelli 60%. The lower the number, the sweeter the chocolate because of the sugar. Definitely do no use unsweetened chocolate. Hope that helps! Happy baking! :)
Emily says: February 4, 2012 LOVE this – I’m tweaking a bit for my superbowl party – Making a maple fudge for the top (with a bit of maple extract) and topping with candied bacon instead of a pretzel. Am using Young’s Double Chocolate stout in lieu of Guinness. Reply
Maureen Leong-Kee - Foodie Du Jour says: March 16, 2012 Found this recipe through Pinterest, and thought it would be great for St. Patty’s Day. I just made them, and they are fantastic! I added a little drizzle of green-dyed white chocolate on the pretzels to be festive. I love that stout, chocolatey flavor with that butterscotch and salty pretzel. Thanks for sharing! Reply
Maryanne says: March 14, 2013 I think you’ll be fine with three large eggs. If you’re worried, you can do three large eggs and then whisk a fourth egg in a separate bowl and use half of it. I think using four large eggs might be a little too much.
Steph says: March 14, 2013 Thanks I just took them out of the oven, look awesome! Will let you know how they taste. I added some butterscotch schnapps and replaced half of heavy cream with baileys – couldn’t resist the extra booze for st pattys!
Carol says: March 10, 2019 I read thru the comments AFTER I made these. I wrongly assumed you meant bakers chocolate and used unsweetened. I gotta tell you, I can not imagine these with sweetened chocolate. They are plenty sweet with the cup of sugars and the mini choc chips. Give it a try. I used a local brewery coffee stout (Ellison Tiramisu Coffee Stout)…holy cow did it turn out great!! Reply
Ashley says: March 8, 2021 Just made these, so good!! I’ve had this recipe saved forever, I’m so glad I finally made it!! Reply